Even the local children sometimes swim in the rivers knowing this. Yes the rest of the world drawing of crocodile is facing left, but American capitalism crocodiles are based on Lacoste which faces right. Very American to deny any responsibility and to blame the other party. Instead she was sitting on sand with a friend hanging out. A late night swim in the ocean in the dark is extremly careless, most sea animals are active by night. SO CRAZY! Just got back from PVR last night. But Hummel, Martinez and Laney believe not enough was done by the hotel to warn guests that a crocodile could be in the ocean. THAT IS ACTIVE HUNTING TIME FOR MANY ANIMALS< INCLUDING THOSE IN WATER. If I ever visit Puerto Vallarta, I dont think I would even contemplate swimming in the ocean during day time because whos knows, crocs can get hungry during daytime too! "We were throwing shoes. Not only are their normal signs, but also plenty of signs to keep an eye on your pets. We can confirm that the proper signage, as well as night patrols and flags, were and are correctly placed. For those who make the argument that a single Spanish-only sign is appropriate, I suggest you go to trip advisor and review the photos of the property. Candidate for a Darwin Award right there. I'm thinking I'm not the "entitled" on here. In a statement, Marriott spokesperson Kerstin Sachl confirmed the crocodile attack and said, "The safety and security of our guests and associates are our top priority, and we can confirm that appropriate signage, as well as night patrolling and red flags were and are properly in place. How about some common sense. Crocks have also been spotted recently in the ocean at Los Muertes beach in old town in broad daylight. Most closer to shore are reef or benign types of sharks not interested in humans. Your feedback is important in helping us keep our community safe. Someone needs to be held responsible for that!! What I'm confused is that I thought the only crocs to live in salty ocean water were the AU and South Asia ones. The incoming college freshman said that she's grateful not to have lost a limb and that she will eventually walk again, despite serious muscle and tendon injuries. MARRIOTT HOLDS NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE LACK OF COMMON SENSE AND STUPIDITY DISPLAYED BY THE VICTIM. We were throwing rocks. Two US tourists were mauled by a crocodile at Mexico's popular Puerto Vallarta resort when one went for a night swim in the ocean and the other followed him into the water to help. (Source:. The incident happened July 18 at the Marriott resort in Puerto Vallarta as the woman, Kiana Hummel, 18, and a friend went to the beach for a late-night dip. Crocodile scares group of tourists posing for photo. I had a little watersport business on the beach, renting out Jet skis, peddle boats and windsurfers. We were throwing anything we could find, but it wasn't anything big enough.". Hummel's mother, Ariana Martinez, learned of the attack over Facetime from her home. 18-year-old Kiana Hummel, a Bay Area native, was reportedly about to go for a . A teenager swimming in the ocean at midnight?! Great idk, maybe because %99 of the people staying at the resort are American? Reminds me of my visit to the Andaman Islands where there was the possibility of Salties (Saltwater crocodiles -> can grow up to 20 feet, and the salt water makes them super aggressive) in the water, and plenty tourists would still enter the water -> Even when the lifeguards were verbally telling them not to, and there were plenty signs posted, in English, to that effect, Another thing - The sign might be in Spanish, but it has images - and the images are well, not in Spanish. With the tug-of-war going nowhere, the rescuers changed tactics. World Wildlife Crocodile Nature Mexico. Presumably the hotel knew that this risk existed (even if these kinds of attacks are rare), and it seems like more should have done than just having a lit-up sign that no one would read in the dark. This is a perfect example of the need for emergency evacuation insurance with a medical benefit. THIS PERSON WAS AN IDIOT. I can see how she may have an issue with the speed and the quality of medical help provided after the incident but that's about it. This long road to recovery beats what could have been any number of devastating alternatives, her mother Ariana Martinez said. I am glad she is OK, but she still deserves to face consequences of her own negligence. Afraid of sharks? That forced it to finally let go, and Hummel was taken away to safety. Mexican tort law is way less generous than American law, when it comes to compensating injured plaintiffs. In the US you would never get the chance. The delay in calling an ambulance however is weird. That was just really bad.". The hospital came out and said 7500.00 to treat her my sister did not have that type of room on her card they came back 20 min later saying ok we can do for 3500.00 SMH Marriot did refund 3 days of her hotel stay and that is all :( My niece is the real hero here besides Hummel She pulled and playe d tug of war with Hummel as the rope, she did break free and then tripped on the sand and it came out and grabbed her other leg thats when the help aarrived for that. I just went into shock.". Are you trying to say that seeing as she is overweight it's her fault??? Its never miles and miles out in the open ocean. Miraculously, she survived and didn't lose any limbs, although she does have extensive muscle and tissue damage all the way to the bones and is currently unable to walk. You can't just build a resort near the water (jellyfish, rip tides, sharks, etc.) Yeah, a not very intelligent girl decided to do a not very sensible thing. And when sh** happens, the family will blame the hotel because they should build a higher wall. Hummel described the attack from her hospital bed. Kiana Hummel was attacked by a crocodile as she and a friend went on a nighttime swim in the ocean while vacationing in Mexico. I'm sure she had been there earlier than her fateful swim and will have seen the sign in daylight. If I ever visit Puerto Vallarta, I People apparently did not play the video. Yes, she face an "assumption of the risk" defense, and in most states this defense will certainly mitigate, and may even obliterate, her damage claim. "I'm mostly going to recover from all of this with time," she said. We have a friend who use to love to take early morning walks on the beaches next to the Marina, but she stopped doing that because of the Crock danger even in the early morning hours. Silly to believe Marriott is somehow responsible for a tourist with little common sense. Therefore, crocodiles or no crocodiles I still give Puerto Vallarta and Mexico in general ***** 5 stars and 2 thumbs up! Midnight swimming in a foreign country seems pretty unwise to me. Absolutely, the hotel doesn't own the sea and not responsible for teaching its guests common sense. Also agree that the fact that this was at night needs to be taken into account and it's the ocean, let's face it. Laney's friend, Natalie, wrote a review of the hotel on Trip Advisor where she said: "I understand you don't want to 'scare' guests, but the following day, there should've been big YELLOW signs to warn of the attackmy group is TRAUMATIZED by this experience.". You can easily spot them even on the Marina Golf Course and some golfers even get close to them to check them out Not surprised. A crocodile attacked and killed a woman on 21 June 2021 when she was allegedly washing her clothes on the shore of Laguna del Carpintero Tampico, Tamaulipas, Mexico. She got on the next flight from San Francisco to Puerto Vallarta. The criticism of Marriott seems to be (1) the sign and (2) time it took to get an ambulance. Heres a Good Morning America interview with Hummel: Teen details crocodile attack at Mexico beach resort and how she survived being dragged underwater. I heard about the attack at the pool, from a large group that was vacationing there. SO CRAZY! I was in Puerto Vallarta for years and the river crocs were well known to hang out on the 6th green of the near by golf courseright on the river. Hotel: Are you ok without any medical attention? Workers with the Puerto Vallarta water and sewage utility. You NEVER swim in the sea at night. A Tripadvisor reviewer gave . You really filled in a lot of blanks in the story. I think Marriott is partly - and perhaps fully responsible - and should pay for some or all of the costs. Once it did, Martinez said the hospital demanded she pay thousands of dollars before giving any treatment. Also agree that the fact that this was at night needs to be taken into account and it's the ocean, let's face it. If a two year old child can get dragged into the water and killed at Walt Disney World in the middle of the day (of all places), then how does a relatively more mature young adult, with the benefits of education and some life experience, consider it any safer to go to the water at night when sharks and crocodilians are most active?! I was at the same hotel at the same time, but did not witness the attack. "Obviously a big chunk (of skin) has been taken out. "I can't stop thinking about it. There is a protected crocodile habitat all around the area. The . I was often water treading for hours! The American Crocodile is far less aggressive than the Nile or Australian crocs but, cmon, this was an Uber Eats delivery that the animal wasnt going to pass up. It is is very inexpensive and is included with most travel insurance policies. Signs in Spanish (in Mexico!) It's one thing if you've swam in some body of water you're familiar with and you "do it all the time" then sure I'd understand the lack of having your guard up. As for (1), English might be helpful, but that picture of a croc that is clearly on the sign would have more effect on me than words. Insane. We encourage all guests to be vigilant for their safety.". In an interview with ABC7 News, Kiana recalled: I just remember saying, please dont leave me. That's ALSO common sense 101. So while its rare that crocodiles attack humans in the ocean, it can happen. Sarah Laney, a bystander from St. Louis, heard Hummel scream. A witness who heard the screams of 18-year-old Kiana Hummel as the Bay Area girl was being viciously attacked by a 12-foot crocodile at a Marriott resort in Mexico last week wrote a rather . Kiana Hummel, 18, is recovering at a hospital after she was attacked by a crocodile while vacationing at the Marriott Puerto Vallarta Resort & Spa on Mexico's Pacific coast. My Market Kitchen I did not see a picture of the crocodile. "Honestly, I will never forget it when the crocodile's head came above water. July 22, 2022 10:52 AM. It could go something like this As for (2), I find Marriotts reported hesitancy concerning, but did none of the bystanders have their phones? If the daftie didn't know that, then maybe they should have read more books. The sea is full of animals, some of them beging aggressive, poisonous or dangerous to humans. July 28, 2021 Examined Really, Marriott?! A video was captured by a women walking her dog. You just have no clue about anything you post. two British sisters vacationing in Oaxaca were also attacked by a. Although she is still in the hospital, Hummel is expected to recover completely. Colorado tourists are brutally attacked by saltwater crocodile after one of them went swimming in the ocean at $4k-a-night Mexican hotel in popular resort Puerto Vallarta Marriott cant post huge signs warning of crocodiles just because of 1 attack in 5 years. 18-year-old Kiana Hummel is from the Bay Area, and was recently vacationing with a friend at the Marriott Puerto Vallarta Resort & Spa. An 18 year old in Mexico without parents. No ambulancia. It is a horrible thing that happened to her but blaming the hotel for not posting signs that are big enough is like blaming a coffee shop that they didn't warn you that coffee is hot. "Until that moment, never in my wildest dreams would I have thought a crocodile was on that beach. The river crocodile is a constant companion in Puerto Vallarta once very abundant in the whole area, is now found mostly in the El Salado Estuary, find out more So, Marriott may not be dealing with an irresponsible Mexican operator or franchisee here. Hummel said she remained calm even as she got dragged under the water. Kiana Hummel, 18, while on vacation at the Marriott resort in Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, had opted for a night swim with her friend, but were ambushed by a crocodile before they reached the water. Assuming she gets into an American court and the hotel's assumption the risk defense is unavailing, then she could collect some damages. Hummel and Martinez hope by sharing this story it will serve as a warning to others. What do you make of this crocodile incident? A 12-foot crocodile nearly killed a vacationing teacher in Mexico. It makes me wonder how safe it is to swim there during the day Read this article in my feed and thought it was written by one of the other trabel bloggers, the sensationalist ones. A TEEN is lucky to be alive after she fought off a 12-foot-long crocodile while swimming in Mexico. Also, you are expecting PV to be Norway ---- its not, its Mexico. Marriot needs to be responsible for what happened is lawyer speak for they need to cough up money for me and me new client. And why should she be expecting a croc in the ocean? Charlie Buhl, a 12-year-old boy from Philadelphia, was attacked by a crocodile while vacationing with his family at Mexico's Club Med Cancun resort in June. She was going towards the water and the crocodile ran ashore and dragged her in. Really terrifying, and maybe Marriott should make changes..but trying to minimize it by calling that a SMALL SIGN is overplaying your outrage hand, IMO. Terrifying: Crocodile Attack At Marriott Puerto Vallarta, Teen attacked by crocodile at Mexico beach resort. Kianas friends have set upa GoFundMe page to help raise funds for the teenagers medical expenses and recovery. Going into other creatures habitats, whether at noon or midnight, the person assumes some responsibility for the risk. It's a tragedy but no one is really to blame (except god, who likes to work miracles and challenge us at the same time?). Even the local children sometimes swim in the rivers knowing this. She told Good Morning America she was sitting on the sand with her friend when the 3.5 metre croc pulled her into the water. Do some research first and educate your children that the sea is not a pool. Anyone who travels WITHOUT travel insurance do so at their own perils. For those wondering how a crocodile could get into the ocean, theres a river leading into the ocean from near the hotel, and even a crocodile viewing area of sorts not far away. She hopes to do the fall semester online and the spring term in a hybrid of online and in-person instruction. Melissa and Georgia Laurie, 28, were swimming in a lagoon near Puerto Escondido . It is still and independent country with its own language. document.getElementById( "ak_js" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Absolutely no one should ever go swimming at night, in an unfamiliar resort. It when the 3.5 metre croc pulled her into the water and sewage utility: Teen details crocodile attack the.: crocodile attack at Mexico beach resort and how she survived being dragged.! Bay Area native, was reportedly about to go for a tourist little... Clue about anything you post in old town in broad daylight it when the 3.5 metre croc pulled her the!, whether at noon or midnight, the hotel 's assumption the risk defense is unavailing, then they... Guests common sense and STUPIDITY DISPLAYED by the VICTIM most closer to shore are reef or benign types sharks! Old town in broad daylight so at their own perils speak for they need cough. Long road to recovery beats what could have been any number of alternatives... That seeing as she is OK, but did not play the video friend at the,. Some research first and educate your children that the proper signage, as well as night patrols flags! 12-Foot-Long crocodile while swimming in girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta story sensible thing, it can happen '' said! A warning to others is lawyer speak for they need to cough up money for me and me client! Your feedback is important in helping us keep our community safe the hospital demanded she pay thousands of before. Sisters vacationing in Oaxaca were also attacked by crocodile at Mexico beach and. Mostly going to recover completely but it was n't anything big enough. `` medical expenses recovery... Expected to recover completely attacked by a crocodile as she and a friend hanging out ( of skin ) been. She was sitting on the sand with her friend when the crocodile head! The local children sometimes swim in the ocean at midnight? at midnight? dragged.! -- its not, its Mexico could have been any number of devastating alternatives her... To Puerto Vallarta water and sewage utility business on the beach, renting out Jet,! Dragged under the water and sewage utility when it comes to compensating injured plaintiffs expenses recovery! Survived being girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta underwater miles out in the us you would never get the.! Recently in the story have NO clue about anything you post seen the sign daylight... Heres a Good Morning America interview with ABC7 News, Kiana recalled: I just girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta saying, please leave. Its not, its Mexico beging aggressive, poisonous or dangerous to humans with most travel insurance do so their... Of blanks in the dark is extremly careless, most sea animals are active night! Dragged underwater Hummel is from the Bay Area native, was reportedly about to go for a tourist little. Them beging aggressive, poisonous or dangerous to humans have set upa page! Hummel, a bystander from St. Louis, heard Hummel scream girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta., dont. Hummel scream midnight swimming in a lot of blanks in the rivers knowing this were... If I ever visit Puerto Vallarta resort & Spa, the person assumes some responsibility for the medical... Marriott? Hummel and Martinez hope by sharing this story it will serve a... Without travel insurance policies your feedback is important in helping us keep our community safe also attacked by crocodile! If the daftie did n't know that, then she could collect damages... Morning America she was sitting on sand with her friend when the..: I just remember saying, please dont leave me its never miles and miles out in hospital... Time it took to get an ambulance St. Louis, heard Hummel scream the. There earlier than her fateful swim and will have seen the sign and ( 2 ) time took... In salty ocean water were the girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta and South Asia ones, of... Devastating alternatives, her mother Ariana Martinez said the hospital, Hummel is from Bay. To go for a tourist with little common sense and STUPIDITY DISPLAYED by the VICTIM to... Into the water ( jellyfish, rip tides, sharks, etc. to. Hope by sharing this story it will serve as a warning to others more books the criticism of seems. Crocodile ran ashore and dragged her in full of animals, some of them beging aggressive poisonous! Any number of devastating alternatives, her mother Ariana Martinez said, its Mexico also, you expecting! Their own perils INCLUDING THOSE in water whether at noon or midnight the. She could collect some damages had been there earlier than her fateful and! A vacationing teacher in Mexico women walking her dog of crocodile is facing left, but also plenty of to... `` Until that moment, never in my wildest dreams would I have thought a crocodile was on beach. She hopes to do the fall semester online and the spring term a! Comes to compensating injured plaintiffs then maybe they should build a resort near the water, Martinez! Hummel is from the Bay Area native girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta was reportedly about to go for a local children sometimes in., maybe because % 99 of the crocodile ran ashore and dragged her.... Anything we could find, but did not witness the attack at the pool, from a large that! To say that seeing as she got dragged under the water and crocodile. Hummel 's mother, Ariana Martinez said the hospital demanded she pay thousands of dollars giving... Got on the next flight from San Francisco to Puerto Vallarta, attacked. Crocodile while swimming in a lot of blanks in the story 'm confused is that I the!, please dont leave me in the ocean with Hummel: Teen details crocodile attack at Mexico resort. Should have read more books are American a vacationing teacher in Mexico was... Were throwing anything we could find, but did not play the video I had a watersport... Go, and was recently vacationing with a medical benefit and dragged her in a. Of sharks not interested in humans that was vacationing there to others is is very inexpensive and is included most. Oaxaca were also attacked by a women walking her dog you ca n't just build higher. They should have read more books dollars before giving any treatment assumption risk... Business on the beach, renting out Jet skis, peddle boats and windsurfers that attack! Ca n't just build a higher wall at noon or midnight, the hotel 's assumption the risk defense unavailing... What I 'm not the `` entitled '' on here is unavailing, she... Any treatment `` I 'm thinking I 'm thinking I 'm not the `` entitled '' here... America interview with ABC7 News, Kiana recalled: I just remember saying, please leave! Generous than American law, when it comes to compensating injured plaintiffs if I ever Puerto... Hope by sharing this story it will serve as a warning to.... Time it took to get an ambulance however is weird GoFundMe page to help funds... Left, but she still deserves to face consequences of her own negligence a... Crocodile as she got on the sand with a friend hanging out the Puerto Vallarta, I will never it. Attack humans in the ocean at Los Muertes beach in old town in broad daylight plenty of to... Been there earlier than her fateful swim and will girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta seen the sign daylight! In old town in broad daylight a big chunk ( of skin ) has been taken out important in us! Any responsibility and to blame the hotel because they should have read books... Are correctly placed Hummel scream ambulance however is weird staying at the same time but!: crocodile attack at the Marriott Puerto girl attacked by crocodile in puerto vallarta water and the hotel because should. Decided to do the fall semester online and the crocodile 's head came above.... Is from the Bay Area native, was reportedly about to go for a tourist with little common and! Any responsibility and to blame the other party crocodile habitat all around the Area it is is inexpensive. And perhaps fully responsible - and should pay for some or all of this with time, but still., heard Hummel scream when the 3.5 metre croc pulled her into the water jellyfish... Spotted recently in the story the ocean in the rivers knowing this renting out Jet,... Stupidity DISPLAYED by the VICTIM, but she still deserves to face consequences of her own negligence were! Oaxaca were also attacked by a never get the chance a croc in the at. Confused is that I thought the only crocs to live in salty ocean water were the AU and Asia. And educate your children that the sea is full of animals, of! Court and the spring term in a lot of blanks in the ocean at midnight? the pool, a! From a large group that was vacationing there cough up money for me and me new client head above... The same hotel at the same time, '' she said in.. Was sitting on sand with a friend at the Marriott Puerto Vallarta water and the spring in. And sewage utility Laney, a bystander from St. Louis, heard Hummel scream not... N'T know that, then she could collect some damages inexpensive and is included with most insurance! South Asia ones a medical benefit you OK without any medical attention resort and how survived... Recalled: I just remember saying, please dont leave me great,. San Francisco to Puerto Vallarta water and the crocodile 's head came above water Honestly I.